Why you shouldn’t ask “When are you having another baby?”

It is important to understand that some question can be painful to someone who is struggling with pregnancy complications or loss.


September 2016

We know that knowing what and what not to say to women about pregnancy can sometimes feel like a minefield, but we think it is important people understand that supposedly innocent questions can have painful consequences for some people.

For the 1 in 4 couples whose pregnancy ends in baby loss, questions about family plans and potential pregnancies can remind them of the heartbreak and disappointment they have suffered and cause further pain.

Blogger MummyFox’s little boy Alfie was just 5 months old when the questions about when she would start trying for another baby started. As Alfie gets older his mum Amy also gets comments like,

“Doesn’t Alfie want a little play mate?”

Sadly, Amy has experienced first-hand the heartbreak of baby loss and knows how hard being faced by these questions can be,

“Maybe the couple you asked have just been through such heartbreak and they wish they were pregnant. I know that I don’t think I’d be able to ask that question again. That may seem extreme but it can hurt. It can hurt a lot. We know.”

The period of time after losing a baby can be whirl of different emotions – grief, anger and even guilt – and whilst parents are struggling to cope with all these feelings a poorly timed or ill-considered question can be a painful reminder of what they have lost.

They can also put bereaved parents in awkward situation where they are pushed into talking about something they don’t want to,

“We don’t want to tell the world what we’ve been through but we also don’t want to not tell anyone and pretend that we are okay. Sometimes we’re not okay. Sometimes the smallest thing can upset us. That question is hard. It can hurt.”

So while the question “When are you having another baby?” may be innocently asked, there are many reasons why it is not alright to ask women this question. As Amy writes,

“You don’t always know what’s going on behind closed doors.”

If someone has confided in you about losing their baby there are things you can say and do to help.

Many couples feel isolated after losing a baby so acknowledging their loss instead of avoiding this painful topic of conversation could really help.

The most important thing you to do is listen. Parents who have lost a baby may want to talk about them or they may not. Being there and hearing what they have to say lets them know that you’re there and you care.

If you have lost a baby, we hope that for every upsetting comment or reaction, you have plenty of love and support around you to help through this difficult time. If you're feeling lost, alone or just in need of a chat, call our midwives on 0800 0147 800 who are trained in bereavement counselling.

Have you been hurt by someone’s reaction or question? Read how other women coped with people’s reactions.

Are you struggling to know what to say to support a loved one after they’ve experienced a loss? Read our advice for supporting someone who has had miscarriage.

Read Amy’s original MummyFox blog post here

Read more Tommy's news and views

  • Picture of Jennie Agg


    A personal meaning of motherhood and Mother's Day

    We asked our lovely friend and supporter, Jennie Agg, what motherhood and Mother's Day means to her. In this piece, she speaks of her difficult past experiences of Mother's Day, how she has grappled with a sense of being in limbo, and the ultimate purity of her feeling of mother love.

  • Collage of photos showing six women who have experienced baby loss, miscarriage and infertility


    Advice to help you cope on Mother’s Day

    In the lead up to Mother's Day, you might find yourself thinking about how to process your emotions and what to do on the day itself. The anticipation can often feel scary or daunting, and finding ways to look after yourself is important. In this blog, you'll find advice from a few of our lovely supporters who understand how you're feeling.

  • Mother holding newborn baby


    Giving some pregnant women progesterone could prevent 8,450 miscarriages a year, say experts

    New research has revealed the benefits of giving progesterone to women with early pregnancy bleeding and a history of miscarriage.

  • Tim Draycott, Clinical Director of Tommy’s National Centre for Maternity Improvement, giving a presentation to audience at the 'Portraying Pregnancy' event


    Tommy's hosts breakfast morning at the Foundling Museum

    Tommy’s spent yesterday morning at the charming Foundling Museum in London, celebrating the work of Tommy’s National Centre for Maternity Improvement alongside the opening of the museum’s new exhibition, ‘Portraying Pregnancy’.

Read more #misCOURAGE stories

  • #misCOURAGE story


    Lane's Story

    I love hearing stories from inspiring women. From birth stories to infertility struggles to adoption stories, I leave each read feeling inspired and in awe of what women face and overcome. After reading a couple of stories and talking with my husband, I decided to share the story of our son Lane.

  • #misCOURAGE story


    Worst week of my life

    Those dreaded words that I didn't want to hear 'I am sorry but you're having a miscarriage'.

  • #misCOURAGE story


    Sharing Bad News is Horrible

    Sadly the scan showed I had lost the baby, there was no heartbeat.

  • #misCOURAGE story


    PCOS and my missed miscarriage

    2 days before my 12 week scan, I noticed some spotting.we had had a missed miscarriage.

    Was this information useful?

    Yes No